Skip to content
IronCoaching

Nordic curls probably protect your hamstrings. The proof is thinner than the headline.

What the research says Nordic hamstring curls do for injury risk, why a reanalysis called it inconclusive, and how low the dose can go in a rugby week.

9 min readBy Abe DearmerPublished Updated

Probably yes, but not as certainly as the headline you have heard. A 2019 meta-analysis of 8,459 athletes found that injury prevention programmes including the Nordic hamstring curl roughly halved hamstring injuries. A 2021 reanalysis of the strongest trials found that effect was no longer statistically certain. The good news is that a small dose looks enough to build the strength the exercise is meant to build.

That matters in rugby because hamstrings are a running injury, and rugby involves a lot of running at speed. It also matters because the exercise is brutal enough that most players quietly stop doing it, and an exercise you have stopped doing protects nothing.

Key takeaways

  • A 2019 meta-analysis of 8,459 athletes found injury prevention programmes that included the Nordic hamstring exercise roughly halved the hamstring injury rate.
  • A 2021 reanalysis using only the trials that truly randomised to the Nordic found the protective effect was no longer statistically certain.
  • Low-volume Nordic programmes built eccentric hamstring strength about as well as high-volume ones in a 2020 meta-analysis.
  • Elite football teams completed the full Nordic programme in only 16 of 150 club-seasons, so a dose players will keep doing matters more than a perfect one.

Do Nordic curls prevent hamstring injuries?

The most cited review says yes. The Nordic hamstring curl is a bodyweight exercise in which you kneel with your ankles held and lower your torso towards the floor as slowly as you can, loading the hamstrings while they lengthen. van Dyk and colleagues pooled 15 studies across sports and found an overall injury risk ratio of 0.49 in favour of programmes that included it.

The finding held up in their own sensitivity checks. Pooling only the 8 studies they classed as randomised gave a risk ratio of 0.52, and removing the 8 studies at high risk of bias gave 0.55. Their conclusion was blunt:

“The NHE essentially halves the rate of hamstring injuries across multiple sports in different athletes.”

van Dyk, Behan and Whiteley, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2019

That sentence is where the “Nordics halve hamstring injuries” claim you see on social media comes from. It is a real finding from a serious review. It is not the last word.

Why do some researchers call the evidence inconclusive?

Because of which studies were counted as trials. Impellizzeri, McCall and van Smeden went back through the same review and found that only 5 of the 15 studies actually randomised players to the Nordic. Using those, plus one newer trial, the risk ratio was 0.59, with a confidence interval of 0.27 to 1.29.

An interval that crosses 1 means the data cannot rule out no effect at all. The point estimate still leans towards protection, so this is not evidence that Nordics fail. It is evidence that the size of the benefit is far less certain than “halves” suggests. In the authors' words:

“The evidence underpinning the protective effect of NHE so far remains inconclusive and mostly derived from high risk of bias RCTs.”

Impellizzeri, McCall and van Smeden, Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2021

The newest review I could find points the same way. A 2026 network meta-analysis by Hong and colleagues, 11 randomised trials and 9,282 football players, found the Nordic on its own showed a modest, non-significant reduction. The FIFA 11+ programme showed the most consistent result at an incidence rate ratio of 0.55. No trial in it was judged low risk of bias, and the authors rated certainty low to very low.

The four studies this article leans on for injury outcomes. A ratio below 1 means fewer injuries. Sources listed below, retrieved via PubMed 21 October 2026.
StudyDesignWhat it found
van Dyk et al., 2019Meta-analysis, 15 studiesRisk ratio 0.49 with the Nordic. Roughly half the injuries.
Impellizzeri et al., 2021Reanalysis, 6 randomised trialsRisk ratio 0.59, interval 0.27 to 1.29. Inconclusive.
Hong et al., 2026Network meta-analysis, 11 trialsNordic alone: modest, not significant. FIFA 11+: 0.55.
Brooks et al., 2006Pro rugby cohortFewer, less severe injuries with Nordics. Association only.

What does the research show in rugby?

Less than in football, and none of it randomised. The rugby study most often cited is Brooks and colleagues' 2006 cohort in professional rugby union, from the Rugby Football Union. Players who did Nordics on top of conventional stretching and strengthening had lower incidence and lower severity of hamstring injuries in training and matches. The authors concluded only that the exercise “may reduce” those injuries.

The same paper is more useful for showing what a hamstring injury costs a rugby player:

  • Matches carry the risk. Incidence was 5.6 per 1,000 player match hours against 0.27 per 1,000 training hours.
  • Time lost. An injury cost 17 days on average.
  • Recurrence is worse. 23% of injuries were recurrences, costing 25 days against 14 for a new injury.
  • Running causes most of them. Running accounted for 68% of hamstring injuries, though injuries from kicking were the most severe at 36 days.

These are professional players from two decades ago, so the exact figures will not match a club side in 2026. The pattern is the useful part: hamstrings go when players sprint in matches, and a second injury costs more than the first.

How many Nordic curls do you actually need?

Fewer than the original programmes asked for, at least for strength. Cuthbert and colleagues pooled 13 studies and found that after 6 weeks or more, eccentric strength improved with very large effect sizes for both high-volume (2.12) and low-volume (2.28) programmes. Their conclusion: cutting the volume did not reduce the strength or muscle architecture adaptations.

A 2025 review in soccer players by Cholp and Zemková adds a caveat. It defined low volume as roughly 1 to 2 sets of 3 to 5 repetitions, 1 to 2 times a week, and high volume as roughly 2 to 3 sets of 8 to 12, 2 to 3 times a week. Both improved eccentric strength, at effect sizes of 0.46 and 0.77. Only high volume meaningfully changed fascicle length and muscle thickness.

Common mistake

Treating stronger hamstrings as the same thing as fewer injuries. These two volume reviews measured strength and muscle architecture, not injury rates. They show that a small dose builds the quality the exercise targets. Whether that small dose prevents injuries as well as a large one has not been tested directly.

Why do so few teams keep doing them?

Because the original programme was hard to sustain. Bahr, Thorborg and Ekstrand surveyed the medical staff of 50 elite football teams over three seasons. Of 150 club-seasons, the Nordic programme was completed in full in only 16 (10.7%), and 83.3% were classed as non-compliant. The authors judged uptake too low to expect any overall effect on injury rates.

Compliance appears to matter for the outcome too. A 2021 meta-analysis by Ripley and colleagues found that compliance above 50.1% had a positive effect on hamstring injury incidence, and that eccentric interventions outperformed other types. The differences between compliance levels did not reach significance, so treat that as a direction rather than a threshold.

Put the volume and compliance findings side by side and the practical reading is clear: the best Nordic programme is the one a player is still doing in round 18.

Where should Nordics go in a rugby week?

Somewhere they cost the least, at a dose low enough to survive the season. What follows is how I apply the research above, not a published result, and it should be read as programming judgement.

  • Start below the low-volume range. Nordics cause heavy soreness when they are new. A first exposure in the middle of a season is not the week to chase sets.
  • Build in pre-season. That is where the window is widest and soreness costs the least. In season, the job is holding what was built at the lowest dose that does it.
  • Keep them away from speed work and match day. Sore hamstrings are a poor match for sprinting, which is the activity most hamstring injuries come from.
  • Do not treat Nordics as the whole answer. The strongest result in the newest review belonged to FIFA 11+, a multi-exercise programme, not to the Nordic on its own.

This is the same reasoning as The Window: rugby has already spent most of a player's capacity before the gym gets any. The same logic sits behind where conditioning goes in the week, covered in does conditioning interfere with strength.

What if you have already torn a hamstring?

Then the next decision is not mine to make. Assessing and rehabilitating a hamstring injury, including when eccentric loading starts and how quickly it builds, belongs to a physiotherapist or doctor. I am neither, and I do not diagnose, treat or clear injuries.

What the research does say is that a previous injury raises the stakes. In the Brooks cohort, recurrent hamstring injuries cost 25 days against 14 for a first injury. That is a reason to get the rehabilitation right with whoever is treating you. Once they clear you to load, the gym work can be built around their clearance rather than ahead of it. The same rule applies to concussion, set out in how long after a concussion you can play rugby again.

Still standing in round 18

Strength work for club rugby built around your fixtures and contact load, with the programming written by me. Application first, then a call. No payment before we talk.

Rugby coaching

Frequently asked questions

Do Nordic hamstring curls prevent hamstring injuries?

Probably, but the evidence is weaker than the famous headline. A 2019 meta-analysis of 8,459 athletes found programmes including Nordics had roughly half the hamstring injury rate. A 2021 reanalysis using only properly randomised trials found the effect was no longer statistically certain. Most trials were in football, not rugby.

How many Nordic curls a week is enough?

Less than the original programmes prescribed. A 2020 meta-analysis found low-volume and high-volume Nordic programmes produced similar eccentric strength gains over six weeks or more. A 2025 review put low volume at roughly one to two sets of three to five repetitions, once or twice a week.

Do Nordic curls work for rugby players?

The rugby evidence is limited. A 2006 cohort study in professional rugby union found players doing Nordics alongside usual stretching and strengthening had fewer and less severe hamstring injuries. It was a cohort study, not a randomised trial, so it shows an association rather than proving the exercise caused the difference.

Why don't more professional teams do Nordic curls?

Mostly because athletes stop doing them. A 2015 survey of 50 elite European football teams found the full programme was completed in only 16 of 150 club-seasons. The authors concluded uptake was too low to expect any effect on injury rates, which is why low-dose versions now attract attention.

Is FIFA 11+ better than Nordic curls alone?

In one 2026 network meta-analysis of football trials, FIFA 11+ showed the most consistent link with fewer hamstring injuries, and Nordics alone showed a modest, non-significant reduction. The authors rated certainty low to very low and warned against treating their ranking as a firm recommendation. Every trial in that review was in football players.

Should I do Nordic curls after a hamstring tear?

Not on my say-so. Rehabilitation after a tear is a physiotherapist's or doctor's call, including when eccentric loading starts and how fast it builds. Once whoever is treating you clears you to load, Nordics can be programmed around that clearance, at the dose and pace they set, not ahead of it.

Sources and references

  1. 1.van Dyk, Behan and Whiteley — Including the Nordic hamstring exercise in injury prevention programmes halves the rate of hamstring injuries: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 8459 athletes15 studies across sports. Source for the overall risk ratio of 0.49, the 0.52 for eight randomised studies, the 0.55 with high-bias studies removed, and the 'essentially halves' conclusion. Br J Sports Med 53(21):1362-1370. Retrieved via PubMed. (2019)
  2. 2.Impellizzeri, McCall and van Smeden — Why methods matter in a meta-analysis: a reappraisal showed inconclusive injury preventive effect of Nordic hamstring exerciseReanalysis of the van Dyk review. Source for only five of 15 studies randomising to the Nordic, the risk ratios of 0.56 and 0.59 with confidence intervals crossing 1, and the 'inconclusive' and conditional-recommendation conclusions. J Clin Epidemiol 140:111-124. Retrieved via PubMed. (2021)
  3. 3.Hong et al. — Comparative Effectiveness of Exercise Interventions for Hamstring Injury Prevention in Football Players: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis11 randomised trials, 9,282 football players. Source for FIFA 11+ at an incidence rate ratio of 0.55, the modest non-significant Nordic-alone estimate, no trial rated low risk of bias, and low to very low certainty. Sports Med Open 12(1):135. Retrieved via PubMed. (2026)
  4. 4.Brooks, Fuller, Kemp and Reddin — Incidence, risk, and prevention of hamstring muscle injuries in professional rugby unionCohort study, level of evidence 3. Source for the training and match incidence figures, 17 days lost on average, the 23% recurrence and its 25 versus 14 days, running as 68% of injuries, and the lower incidence in players doing Nordics. Am J Sports Med 34(8):1297-1306. Retrieved via PubMed. (2006)
  5. 5.Bahr, Thorborg and Ekstrand — Evidence-based hamstring injury prevention is not adopted by the majority of Champions League or Norwegian Premier League football teams: the Nordic Hamstring surveySurvey of 50 elite teams, 2012 to 2014. Source for the full programme completed in 16 of 150 club-seasons (10.7%), 83.3% non-compliant, and the conclusion that uptake was too low to affect injury rates. Br J Sports Med 49(22):1466-1471. Retrieved via PubMed. (2015)
  6. 6.Cuthbert et al. — The Effect of Nordic Hamstring Exercise Intervention Volume on Eccentric Strength and Muscle Architecture Adaptations: A Systematic Review and Meta-analyses13 studies. Source for the eccentric strength effect sizes of 2.12 for high volume and 2.28 for low volume after six weeks or more, and the conclusion that lower volumes do not reduce those adaptations. Sports Med 50(1):83-99. Retrieved via PubMed. (2020)
  7. 7.Cholp and Zemková — Effect of high vs. low volume of the nordic hamstring curl on hamstring muscle architecture and eccentric strength in soccer players: a systematic review and meta-analysis11 studies in soccer players. Source for the high and low volume definitions, the strength effect sizes of 0.77 and 0.46, and the finding that only high volume changed fascicle length and muscle thickness. Front Physiol 16:1631205. Retrieved via PubMed. (2025)
  8. 8.Ripley et al. — The Effect of Exercise Compliance on Risk Reduction for Hamstring Strain Injury: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses13 studies. Source for compliance above 50.1% having a positive effect on hamstring injury incidence, eccentric interventions outperforming other modalities, and the compliance differences not reaching significance. Int J Environ Res Public Health 18(21):11260. Retrieved via PubMed. (2021)

Research findings are summarised from the abstracts of the cited papers, retrieved via PubMed on 21 October 2026, and most of the trials are in football rather than rugby. Where the article describes how I would place Nordics in a week, that is my coaching judgement, not a finding. I am not a physiotherapist or doctor, and nothing here is medical advice or a substitute for assessment of an injury.

Abe Dearmer

Coach and founder, IronCoaching

Served 14 years as an officer in the Australian Army’s Artillery. Competes in powerlifting with a published record, and holds Rugby Australia Pathways & Performance Coach accreditation.

Related

Last reviewed . Figures on this page are rechecked against their sources rather than left to go stale.