Your conditioning is not stealing your strength. It might be stealing your speed.
Two meta-analyses on running and lifting in the same week: what conditioning costs your strength, what it costs your power, and where to put it instead.
For maximal strength and muscle size, no — the best current evidence finds no meaningful interference. A 2022 meta-analysis of 43 studies found one real cost: smaller gains in explosive strength, and mostly when conditioning and lifting shared a session. Where you put the running matters more than whether you do it.
That matters if you play a sport, because you cannot choose between running and lifting. Your sport decides the conditioning. What you can decide is how the week is arranged around it, and that is where most of the cost is either paid or avoided.
Key takeaways
- A 2022 meta-analysis of 43 studies found adding conditioning did not reduce gains in maximal strength or muscle size.
- It did reduce gains in explosive strength — and more so when both were done in the same session.
- Separating sessions by at least three hours removed the significant effect on explosive strength.
- In season, strength held for up to 32 weeks on one heavy session a week in the general population. Intensity is what keeps it.
Does conditioning reduce strength gains?
Not measurably, for the two qualities most people worry about. Schumann and colleagues pooled 43 studies comparing concurrent aerobic and strength training against an identical strength program with no aerobic work, in healthy adults training for at least four weeks. The standardised mean difference for maximal strength was −0.06, and for muscle size −0.01. Neither came close to significance.
| Outcome | Effect size | p | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Maximal strength | −0.06 | 0.446 | No effect |
| Explosive strength | −0.28 | 0.007 | Reduced |
| Muscle size | −0.01 | 0.919 | No effect |
The authors' conclusion is direct: concurrent training does not compromise muscle hypertrophy and maximal strength development. If the fear keeping you out of the gym is that your fitness work will cancel your squat, that fear is not supported by the pooled data.
What does it cost you, then?
Explosive strength — producing force quickly, which is most of what a sport actually asks of your legs. The same review found a standardised mean difference of −0.28 for explosive strength, and this one was significant. It is a modest effect, but it lands on the quality that sprinting, jumping and changing direction depend on.
The older evidence points the same way. Wilson and colleagues' 2012 meta-analysis, 21 studies and 422 effect sizes, found power gains with strength training alone at an effect size of 0.91 against 0.55 with conditioning added. Of the three qualities they measured, power took the largest proportional hit.
Judging the interference by your squat. The squat is the quality the research says is safe. The quality at risk is the one you are least likely to test — how fast you can apply force — so an athlete can feel strong and still be losing the part that shows up on the field.
Why do the two big reviews disagree about running?
Because they pooled different studies, a decade apart. The 2012 review found that running, but not cycling, significantly reduced gains in both hypertrophy and strength, and that the frequency and duration of endurance training were negatively related to strength, size and power outcomes.
The 2022 update, with roughly twice the studies, found no significant difference between cycling and running, and none between more or fewer than five weekly concurrent sessions. On modality, the newer and larger analysis should carry more weight.
I would not throw the older finding away entirely, though. The volume signal in it is intuitive: every extra hour of running is recovery the gym does not get. The newer review did not find a frequency effect at its cut-off, which is not the same as proving that volume never matters. Where the two agree, trust it. Where they disagree, treat volume as something to watch rather than something to fear.
Should you run and lift in the same session?
If you can avoid it, yes, avoid it. The 2022 review found the loss of explosive strength was more pronounced when both were done in the same session (p = 0.043), and not significant when sessions were separated by at least three hours. That is the most practical single finding in this literature.
On the question everyone asks next — lift first or run first — the review analysed exercise order, but the finding its abstract reports is about separation, not sequence. I would rather tell you that than invent a rule. If the calendar forces both into one session, the separation finding is the one to plan around: put the work you most need to be fast for where you are freshest.
Morning gym, evening training is the easiest version of the three-hour gap for most club athletes. A gym session at lunch and a team session at night clears it without adding a day.
How little strength work holds your strength in season?
Less than most athletes assume. A 2021 review by Spiering and colleagues found that in younger people, strength and muscle size could be maintained for up to 32 weeks on one strength session a week and one set per exercise — provided relative load stayed high. Endurance held for up to 15 weeks on as few as two sessions a week, again if intensity was kept.
Their conclusion is the useful part: intensity is the key variable, and frequency and volume can drop a long way before performance does. In season, that means the heavy work stays heavy and gets shorter, rather than staying long and getting light.
Worth being careful here: the authors state plainly that there is insufficient data to make specific recommendations for athletes. Those figures come from general populations. They set the floor, not the target.
What can the research not tell you?
Three things, and they matter for anyone who plays seriously.
- Who was studied. The 2022 review compared untrained and recreationally active adults. Highly trained athletes are not a separate group in it, so the findings are a starting point, not a rule written for you.
- What conditioning means in sport. These studies prescribe running or cycling. Your conditioning is also contact, repeated sprints and match minutes, which no lab protocol fully reproduces.
- Your own week. A meta-analysis gives an average effect. It cannot tell you what three games in nine days will do to your Thursday session.
That last point is the gap coaching fills, and it is why I would not hand you a template off the back of these papers.
How should the week be built?
Around the conditioning you cannot move, rather than on top of it. This is how I apply the findings above; it is my programming judgement, not a published result, and it is stated as one.
- Heavy strength work is not the fragile part. Keep it heavy, and cut volume before load when the week gets crowded.
- Speed and power work is the fragile part. Put it where the legs are freshest, away from the hardest running, and never tack it onto the end of a conditioning session.
- Separate gym and running by three hours or more wherever the calendar allows. A different day is better still.
- Watch total running volume across the week, including what your team session adds, rather than the gym session in isolation.
This is the reasoning behind The Window: every athlete has a band of load they can absorb, and the sport has already spent most of it. The gym gets what is left, placed where it costs the least. The same logic applies to rugby and to ADF applicants building a beep test alongside push-ups.
Stronger, without getting slower
Strength work built around a season someone else controls, with the programming written by me. Application first, then a call — no payment before we talk.
Frequently asked questions
Does cardio kill strength gains?
Not maximal strength or muscle size, on the best current evidence. A 2022 meta-analysis of 43 studies found no meaningful difference in either when aerobic training was added to an identical strength program. What it did find was a smaller gain in explosive strength, the ability to produce force quickly.
Is running worse than cycling for strength?
The evidence is split. A 2012 meta-analysis found running, but not cycling, reduced strength and hypertrophy gains. The larger 2022 update found no difference between the two. The honest reading is that modality matters less than once thought, and that how much you run still deserves attention.
Should I lift or run first?
The better question is whether to split them at all. The 2022 review found the loss of explosive strength was more pronounced when both were done in the same session, and not significant when sessions were at least three hours apart. It reports no finding on order that I can quote.
How much strength training do I need in season?
Less than most athletes fear. A 2021 review found strength and muscle size in younger people held for up to 32 weeks on one session a week and one set per exercise, provided the load stayed heavy. The authors say the data are too thin for athlete-specific prescriptions.
Will conditioning make me slower?
It can blunt gains in explosive qualities, which is the one cost the 2022 meta-analysis found. That is not the same as making you slower than you are now. It means speed and power work needs protecting in the week, with fresh legs and distance from the heaviest conditioning.
Does this apply to elite athletes?
Only partly. The 2022 review pooled healthy adults who were untrained or recreationally active, and found no difference between those groups. Highly trained athletes are under-represented in this research, so treat the findings as a strong starting point rather than a rule written for professionals.
Sources and references
- 1.Schumann et al. — Compatibility of Concurrent Aerobic and Strength Training for Skeletal Muscle Size and Function: An Updated Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis43 studies, healthy adults, supervised training of at least four weeks. Source for the maximal strength, explosive strength and hypertrophy effect sizes, the same-session versus three-hour finding, and the absence of a running versus cycling difference. Sports Med 52(3):601-612. Retrieved via PubMed. (2022)
- 2.Wilson et al. — Concurrent training: a meta-analysis examining interference of aerobic and resistance exercises21 studies and 422 effect sizes. Source for the strength, hypertrophy and power effect sizes by group, the running-not-cycling finding, and the negative relationship with endurance frequency and duration. J Strength Cond Res 26(8):2293-2307. Retrieved via PubMed. (2012)
- 3.Spiering et al. — Maintaining Physical Performance: The Minimal Dose of Exercise Needed to Preserve Endurance and Strength Over TimeNarrative review. Source for the one-session, one-set maintenance figure, the endurance maintenance figures, intensity as the key variable, and the authors' own caveat that data for athletes are insufficient. J Strength Cond Res 35(5):1449-1458. Retrieved via PubMed. (2021)
Research findings are summarised from the abstracts of the cited papers, retrieved via PubMed on 23 September 2026, and each carries its own limitations — several are stated in the text rather than hidden. How I apply them to a training week is my coaching judgement, not a finding. Nothing here is medical advice.
Abe Dearmer
Coach and founder, IronCoaching
Served 14 years as an officer in the Australian Army’s Artillery. Competes in powerlifting with a published record, and holds Rugby Australia Pathways & Performance Coach accreditation.
Related
Sports Performance
The pillar page this article sits under, with the full picture rather than one question.
All articles
Every piece, with its sources named and the date its figures were last checked.
Coaching
Four tiers, billed weekly, by application, with a call before any payment. Or a one-off program you buy directly.